Many domain investors get frustrated when they feel they have the right domain for the right buyer yet cannot close a sale.
There can be many reasons why a prospect chooses not to buy what seems like a sure match.
1) Living inside the domaining bubble
Those who reside outside the domain industry do not have as much interest or passion about domains as you do. For many it is not the greatest thing they could do for their business, it is more a basic utility for them to be found on the net. Those inside the industry spend their days registering, bidding and discussing domain names. Conversations tend to focus on the importance of a domain name, you just have to realize everyone does not share that opinion.
2) Difference of opinion on quality
Sometimes you think a name is of far greater quality than the prospect does. Yes, if you own the non hyphenated version it is of higher quality than the hyphenated version currently in use. The prospect may think that is worth $100 while you feel it is worth $5,000.
Other times the name is not really as good as the domain owner thinks. Sometimes you are in love with a domain and tend to have a higher opinion of the name than anyone else.
3) Some see you as a squatter
No matter how good a generic, non tm infringing domain may actually be, some see you as a squatter, pirate, parasite and they will never buy the domain for anything other than the cost of registration fee.
4) Email communications are not connecting
You need to know who to contact when you do email marketing to try to sell your domain names. Some just send an email to firstname.lastname@example.org and wait for a reply.
These emails may go to spam or to a low – level employee that does not know what to do with such emails.
5) The Pitch
You may get the email to the correct person but your pitch is no good or not striking the right chord. You need to make sure you test different email templates.
You might want to consider using the phone if you feel you are better with live chat over email.
These are not the only reasons you may not get that sale but they are high on the list. Keep testing and documenting what does and does not work for you.